# No.1160 (SD)

 No.1160  Stephan Dietrich (Германия) Оригинальные задачи, Julia’s Fairies – 2016 (II): июль – декабрь    →Предыдущая ; →Следующая ; →Список 2016(II) Пожалуйста, присылайте свои оригинальные сказочные задачи на: julia@juliasfairies.com

Определения: (показать/спрятать)

 No.1160 Stephan Dietrich Germany original – 27.11.2016 Solution: (click to show/hide) white TRf4 MSg5 POg7 black POh8 #4                                                (3+1) Triton f4 Marine Knight g5 Poseidon g7, h8 1.POg7-f6 ! threat: 2.TRf4-h4 threat: 3.POf6-g6 zugzwang. 3...POh8-g8 4.TRh4-h8 # 2...POh8-g8 3.TRh4-h8 + 3...POg8-g7 + 4.POf6-g6 # { (C+ by Popeye 4.75)}

### 12 комментариев: No.1160 (SD)

1. Joost пишет:

Why a marine knight on g5? A pawn works just as well.

• seetharaman пишет:

hm… you are right. g5 is only used a block the black poseidon,so it can be pawn. perhaps the composer wanted an all marine board !

2. Nikola Predrag пишет:

Something is wrong with my perception of the essential features of the position. Not only about White in check, but about how Black could have delivered that check.

After that, the bizarre Popeye’s “solution”, illegally skipping B1, looks as a minor issue.

• seetharaman пишет:

black could have captured a white piece from h6 to h8.

3. seetharaman пишет:

I am sorry…. from h6 white is already in check.

4. Geoff Foster пишет:

In the given solution, the first line (with missing moves) is the threat. The full solution is:

1.POf6! POg8,POh7 2.TRh4 POh8 3.POg6 POg8 4.TRh8#
2…POg8,POf8 3.TRh8+ POg7+ 4.POg6#

5. Nikola Predrag пишет:

Threat is a real variation AFTER some irrelevant random MOVE. No move, no variation and no real threat since it’s simply impossible.

6. seetharaman пишет:

Is it a no solution after 1…POg8 2.TRh4? POh8! 3.TRh3? POg8! 4.TRh8+?

• Joost пишет:

2…POh8 3. POg6

• seetharaman пишет:

oh… got it. It should have been given as variation.

7. Juraj Lörinc пишет:

I find it quite sad that there is long discussion below almost worthless composition, while many worthy problems remain without any comment from readers.

8. Nikola Predrag пишет:

The “almost” worthless composition is not a chess-composition at all in the first place, as being a nonsense with regards to the Chess.

The discussion is by far TOO SHORT with regards to the serious recent increase of nonsense everywhere.
But who cares!? 🙁