Fair criticism, even if a little harsh !
On No.634 (LG)
bPh4 can move to g3 only if g3 is occupied by some opponent's piece. So wP must already occupy g3…
On No.636 (GF)
Geoff, It seems that Popeye at least tries to obey the standard ep.-rules and admits that bP was captured on…
On No.636 (GF)
Roughly speaking, I see an EP-piece as a policeman along a road. If you drive too fast while crossing the…
On No.636 (GF)
Yes Nicolas, I tried to express it shortly and it was not clear enough. Literally, a2-a4 is not a fairy…
On No.636 (GF)
It seems there is a bug in Popeye whereby en passant is not allowed with anti-Take&Make. The best way to…
On No.636 (GF)
No.634 Grolman - Generally speaking the Four fold cyclic white batteries’ creation is a super theme. Therefore, the author is…
On No.634 (LG)
Dominique, the relevant question is whether b2 reached b4 after the ep-sequence. And both Popeye and WinChloe answer “yes” (see…
On No.636 (GF)
Literally, bPa4 is an completely orthodox piece because it is defined by orthodox rules. The same is about wPb2 and…
On No.636 (GF)
Geoff is giving his own notation for the solution, which is not the one used by WinChloe. Rules are still…
On No.636 (GF)
